a worldwide christian training and counseling organization

Categorized | Article by Tracy Keen

Culture and homeschool can create the same problem: pre-mature kids

FacebookGoogle+LinkedInTumblrPinterestStumbleUponShare

What is the one thing a Christian parent can’t stand about the effect media and advertising is having on their young girls?

Christians make the claim that daughters are growing up too fast as a result of advertisers pushing young girls to display their sexuality either in talk, dress and or experiences. I agree.

Just take a look at some of the tween/teen magazines. You will get an eye full of the over sexualization of young girls. The subject matter in these magazines is not age appropriate and definitely stirs up emotions in young girls, challenging them to have experiences they are not yet mature enough to handle.

The clothing considered “in style” for young girls does not display modesty and the girls in the ads are getting younger and younger. It’s alarming.

As a Christian woman, a wife, and a mother, I too am very disturbed by the sexualization of young girls. But recently, I have come across another trend equally disturbing to me.

Christians producing pre-mature girls

As the media and advertisers push sexualization on our daughters, some Christians can make the same mistake by pushing pre-maturity just as hard on their daughters and doing it in the name of godliness. What am I referring to?

Simply this, too many young girls in the Christian world are also losing out on their childhood innocence as their parents push and prod them to mature faster than they are ready.

While this trend can be found in any Christian home, I am seeing a bigger push within the home school movement. Some home school movements over-emphasize pre-maturity, seemingly as an effort to prove their children are smarter or more mature than children who attend public or private schools.

The shift has taken a new turn as these home school parents push their children to mature before they are ready, especially with daughters. Within my own local home school group I have noticed young girls who are definitely in that awkward, in between stage of no longer being a child, but not yet a woman.

Some of the girls are still allowed to be young and mature at a slower rate while some of the girls are being pushed into womanhood before being ready.

As a former young girl myself, I understand the awkwardness all girls feel when they are maturing into a young woman, but notice I said young woman.

Somehow, we have removed the young part of our daughters’ lives and moved them from childhood straight to womanhood. We have pushed our daughters to mature into women and given them responsibilities that are not age appropriate.

Stop by our store and pick up two FREE eBooks: So, You Want to Get Married? and Small Group Life–Envisioning, Equipping, & Enjoying

Little women?

How many times do you see young girls who are taking care of their younger siblings or taking on large responsibilities in the home? I am all for teaching our daughters how to run a home and how to take care of babies and children, and using their own siblings and their own homes is a great way to teach and train them.

This is definitely less expensive than having to rent out a family. However, I am not for pushing the responsibility of the mother over to these young girls to raise younger siblings or take care of the homes when mom is overwhelmed.

Yes, it is helpful to have your daughter be able to help with the household responsibilities in a pinch, but it is not her responsibility to run your home.

How can a young girl be expected to teach younger children the ins and outs of life when she is still in the thick of maturing herself? This is the job of older women and I think older women need to step up to the plate.

Within this trend, I notice a push to have younger girls wear clothing that is more modest than the rest of the world, but leans more towards looking like a miniature version of what mom wears.

The young daughter has the same hair style as mom, wears the same amount of makeup as mom and even the same style clothing as mom. No room for being a young individual girl here.

These girls find it hard to talk with other girls of the same age as they can’t relate to their peers because of the different pressures they face at home.

They are more comfortable talking with older moms about the hardships of running a household, keeping up with laundry, disciplining the children, and eking more money out of the family budget.

Are these things our daughters need to learn? Yes, but it needs to be at a more gradual pace in line with the actual maturity of the girl.

Young girls should not be burdened with the stress of the family budget or the frustration of dealing with rebellious children. Trust me, they will get that opportunity when they marry and start their own family.

Teach your daughters how to handle these things by example and give them Biblical wisdom in these areas, but don’t push those responsibilities onto them in your home.

In due season

Another aspect of this trend is the idea that young, inexperienced women, who are not married and do not yet have children, are fit to teach older women how to run their homes. I admit when I was younger I thought I too knew everything, even though I had not actually experienced running a home.

I was the best wife, mother, and woman in theory until I actually became one. Experience is not everything, but in this area, it sure does help.

Within the home school movement you can see this trend if you attend a home school conference. You will notice how many home school children are actually giving lectures and presentations to the homeschooling parents.

There is a big difference in being a homeschooled child and being a homeschooling parent. The responsibilities are completely different. The pressures and frustrations are not yet realized by these young inexperienced women (and men) who have not actually had to teach their own children.

Imagine my giving a seminar to older women on the effects of menopause and trying to convince them I know a better way for them to deal with it all when I have not yet gone through menopause.

Can I as a younger woman explore these things? Yes, and when that time comes for me, you can bet I am going to go to an older woman and ask for her knowledge and expertise in this area, not a younger woman who is in the thick of having babies.

Each home is different

If you are the mother of a daughter, you have to assess your own home and not fall into the trap of comparing it with another home. Don’t push your daughter to mature at the same rate of another girl in your circle.

Not that we dare to classify or compare ourselves with some of those who are commending themselves. But when they measure themselves by one another and compare themselves with one another, they are without understanding. – 2 Corinthians 10:12 (ESV)

The young girl who dresses more modestly, is capable of running a home, or has input on topics above the knowledge level of her peers is not necessarily godlier than other young girls.

In fact, there is a greater danger of raising up a Pharisee, someone who shows forms of godliness on the outside but with no change on the inside.

The desire for modesty, pure speech, taking care of a home, etc. should be taught and modeled to our daughters, but not forced onto them from the outside.

Read our 12 short Life Lessons for Teenagers articles

Girls raised in Christian homes need to be free to still be innocent, fun-loving children, tweens, teens, and then young women.

If the heart of your daughter has truly been changed by Christ and she is given the time she needs to mature as a result of your Godly training, you will begin to see her develop into a Godly young woman first and then on to a Godly woman.

For further reading on our Member Site

Powered By DT Author Box

Written by Tracy Keen

Tracy Keen

Tracy is the grateful wife of US Air Force Officer Carlton Keen. She is also the mother to her four boys, one who is already with Christ.

After completing a B.A. from the University of West Florida in Public Relations, Tracy attended the New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary and obtained her M.Div in Christian Thought.

She has a desire to witness to the church and bring the message of repentance and salvation to all those who need the Savior.

Print Friendly
FacebookGoogle+LinkedInTumblrPinterestStumbleUponShare
  • Lisa H.

    I think the balance is what is essential. As Tracy said, we do need to teach modesty and the care of the home without overdoing it. I have a special needs son with severe issues and have always taught his older sisters to pitch in and help out, but have refrained from letting them handle too much of his care. I agree with Tracy that girls and boys alike should feel their place in the family and at the same time feel nurtured and not forced to take on too much before they are ready.

  • Carolina

    How in the world do you not know that the daughters do not know what the Biblical principles for modesty are? Aren’t you assuming too much here?

    Aren’t you also a bit concerned as a Christian how divisive your post is??? I mean, what will the families in you co-op think now that you have basically pointed them out and stereotyped them like this!!???

    In all honesty, I am more concerned about young ladies/girls/tweens who aren’t being taught enough or aren’t maturing. My mother wasn’t very nurturing…..I had to learn all domestic duties once I was married! I wish she would have taught me more in the areas of domestic economics :)

    I think if I would have read this post 10-15 years ago, I probably would have agreed with you but now that I am homeschooling my 2 boys and I am around more of the homeschooling circles………….I just don’t see what you’re seeing.

  • Tracy Keen

    A need for some clarification on my part. Thank you to those who pointed out what is wrong with daughters wanting to look like their moms. Nothing is wrong with that. I see it a lot and it is sometimes really cute.
    Here is what I wrote:
    Within this trend, I notice a push to have younger girls wear clothing that is more modest than the rest of the world, but leans more towards looking like a miniature version of what mom wears.
    The young daughter has the same hair style as mom, wears the same amount of makeup as mom and even the same style clothing as mom. No room for being a young individual girl here.
    I see where this comment caused a few eyebrows to be raised. I am not against a younger girl wanting to dress like her mother. What concerns me is a young girl who dresses like her mom, in ways that are yes, probably more modest than the world, but she herself has no idea what the Biblical principles for modesty are. The Biblical principles for modesty need to be taught to our daughters and not just enforced on them.
    Another point of clarification on my part – I wrote:
    Imagine my giving a seminar to older women on the effects of menopause and trying to convince them I know a better way for them to deal with it all when I have not yet gone through menopause.
    Can I as a younger woman explore these things? Yes, and when that time comes for me, you can bet I am going to go to an older woman and ask for her knowledge and expertise in this area, not a younger woman who is in the thick of having babies.
    Some brought out the fact that I do not yet have daughters and that is true. But please know I wrote this article from research of several women in the home school movement who do see this trend and are very concerned. I realize some of you may not agree with their thoughts (or mine included), but please don’t discredit the struggles they are dealing with in their home school circles.
    As a mother who does not yet have daughters, I am exploring these things. I am very concerned about the pressures my daughters will face in the home school world. I am not an authority on how to raise daughters, and I do apologize if my article came across that way. I would not even be a good authority on how to raise boys. I do wish with all sincerity that a movement as great as the home school movement, and one which I am very much a part of, would not place itself above questioning, sharpening, or expression of concern.
    Thanks again for those who sharpened me in my writing, I really do appreciate it and hope to learn from your comments.
    Tracy

  • http://www.facebook.com/janet.billson Janet Billson

    Mikee, I appreciate your comments. Thank you.

  • zKatherine

    You make some very good points, especially warning worn-out mothers not to lean too heavily on their older girls for help in running the household. There needs to be a difficult balance between learning how to run a home, for which both BOYS and girls should be taught, and giving them too much of what should be the mother and father’s responsibility.

    Where I differ though is in your comments about the girls dressing like their mothers. If they were in school, wouldn’t they then want to dress like their peers? All kids want to fit in to their environments. I’d much rather see young girls mimic the modest dress of their mothers than mimic many of the latest immodest fashions that I see middle schoolers and high schoolers wearing these days.

  • Tracy Keen

    Again, Thank you to all for your comments. I appreciate your feedback, iron sharpens iron. I just want to make it clear that I am not against home school. I am very much in the thick of it and am grateful I have the opportunity to teach my children, love it. For those of you who have not had to experience the difficulties mentioned in the article or don’t see it in your local groups, I say, wonderful. But for some of us in the home school network, this is a problem. My article was written with those in mind. The mothers I questioned in regards to this article gave me much insight into the difficulty of raising a daughter and how there can sometimes be pressure from a great movement like home school to move their daughters along in maturity too fast. Yes, we do the same things with our sons, but this article focused on girls as I am currently learning a lot about raising girls. Since I do not have daughters yet, I am very thankful to the insight from other moms on this topic as it was something I was concerned about but did not feel I could say too much about because of the fact that I don’t have a daughter. In short, I wanted to make sure what I was seeing was not just something I imagined as a problem for mothers of daughters, but was in fact a reality for some.
    Yes, I do realize terms like teen and tween are not specifically mentioned in the Bible. There are other terms we use in our culture and even in the church to refer to something which is not specifically mentioned in the Bible, like the term home school, but the concept is there and it can be easily recognized and understood by others. This article was written to encourage those who are dealing with this problem and are in the thick of it. To remind them that Godliness has to be worked from the inside out through the gospel of repentance and faith. And yes, God can use a parent and their home school efforts to make this hope a reality. Be encouraged all you home school parents. Keep fighting the good fight which is not always the easy way.

  • Mikee

    I am a homeschooling dad of three girls and a son. I have never been to a home school conference and this could certainly show up there but I have never seen it in our home school circles.

    The Bible never once makes the kind of distinction that Tracy makes about girl/young girl/tween/teen/young woman. It just isn’t there. Additionally since these terms could mean totally different things to different people it would have been more helpful to use ages. More people would be concerned about an 8-year old tending a baby than a 12 or 13-year old.

    When I read something like “The shift has taken a new turn as these home school parents push their children to mature before they are ready, especially with daughters.”, it’s hard to think that Tracy isn’t imposing her view of propriety on others. I am inclined to believe that moms and dads know their individual kids better than outside observers. Tracy assumes that because she observes this that mothers are pushing daughters into it. What is wrong with daughters wanting to emulate their moms and it being demonstrated in the ways Tracy mentions?

    The inconsistency problem is not that Tracy does not have grounds to speak truth to parents of daughters when she doesn’t have daughters, but that she uses that liberty without affording it to others. We should test everything and hold onto the good, and there are lots of helpful things parents can gain by listening to kids talk about homeschooling. Parents are capable of discerning good from bad with the guide of the Holy Spirit. (Anecdotally, I really would not have any problems with Tracy talking about menopause in lots of ways including something like showing how putting our hope in our physical bodies doing what we want rather than attaching our hope to Christ is dangerous and destructive.)

    I could go on but the article would have been much more beneficial if it had been more specific. Specificity based on actual cases and circumstances is what makes Rick’s articles that appear here so immensely helpful.

  • Karen Butler

    “I know for myself that it was not the teacher as much as the fact that
    the teaching appealed to the pharisee in me and the fear in my parents. I
    am thankful for the years at Mt. Sinai because of the joy I now know
    through grace. The law is a harsh taskmaster but it makes Christ that
    much sweeter.” Amen!

    I appreciate how honoring to your teachers you are. I have been through some hard places with my girls — for a lot of the reasons you cite, my eldest was given too much responsibility too soon. She was so darn competent, and I was so overwhelmed and soon the eldest two threw off the denim jumpers and sported mohawks and worse until it

    “dead-ended with runaways being miraculously apprehended. And then a
    healing season of therapeutic boarding schools for two of them and
    marriage counseling for my husband and I. In these afflictions I was
    humbled and clung desperately to God and to every word from His mouth
    and not on the false promises of false prophets and self titled experts
    and all their formulas that fix, and happy pills that miss, and magic
    wands that terrify.” (from
    http://thenface2face.wordpress.com/2010/03/28/stand-with-an-open-heart-what-frog-and-toad-can-teach-us-about-what-lydia-schatz-might-have-said/)

    I have given up on homeschooling support groups and conventions — they no longer speak my language. You sound closer to my tribe. We have piercings and interesting tats. I will check out your site. Thank you so much for your encouraging post.

  • Tracy Keen

    Thank you to all for your comments. To answer some questions, I was not a homeschooler growing up, I attended public schools. I am now homeschooling my children. No, I do not have daughters yet, but am attempting to have some through adoption. So even though I don’t have the experience of raising a daughter, I am looking at what is going on in the home school world as I hope to home school my daughters. I was fortunate enough to have some home schooling mamas with daughters to preview my article and they shared in the concern and the admission that it is not easy raising a daughter.
    Why would a mother of boys be interested in what is going on with girls??? Well, simply put, my sons will one day be looking for a wife. I hope to teach them to look at the heart of a woman and not at her outer abilities. To discern if her heart has been changed and matured by Christ or by others.
    I have had the experience of attending home school seminars. I am concerned about what is going on with the boys as well which one person commented on already. I am equally concerned about the trend of not encouraging our young people to mature – I could write a different article on that altogether. The point of this article was to show an extreme and to show how their needs to be balance. The article was meant to be a reminder that whether your child attends public, private, or is home schooled, parents need to rely on Christ to grow and mature their child. We are called to do our part in training and discipling, but ultimately, the change has to come from Him. Inside out, not outside in. Again, good comments. Thank you for taking the time to think through a tough topic.
    Tracy

  • Janet

    Tracy, have you ever had any contact with the Mennonites? In our area there are Mennonite families whose daughters work alongside their mothers, and dress in dresses like their mothers, and take on the responsibility of caring for home and younger children as they are capable. The sons work in the barns and fields with their fathers, too. They seem to be happy, healthy, loving children growing up in an environment that teaches them to be responsible adults.

    I was a little taken aback by the tone of this article. It seems critical to me. Of course there is a valid caution that all parents ought to be careful in raising their children, but who are we to look at other families and decide that they are making bad choices?

    What is important is the internal – the heart before God. If the parents’ hearts are turned towards God and they are desiring to raise up their children in the nurture and admonition of the Lord, what is external (dress, chores, etc.) doesn’t matter.

    I am also curious as to whether you were homeschooled, or if you homeschool your sons yourself.

    I agree with you that young women ought not to be teaching older women how to run a household. That said, if a particular young woman had studied a particular area in depth so as to be an expert, I’d have no problem sitting under her tutelage. In Titus, the older women are admonished to teach the younger women, and that seems to be more valuable in most cases.

    There is always a danger of raising up a Pharisee; there is also a danger of raising a prodigal, or a rebel. Every parent must learn to lean on the Lord for His wisdom, and to be grateful for His grace displayed in godly offspring.

  • http://www.RickThomas.Net/ Rick Thomas

    Hey Cathy – a good thought. Thank you for sharing. My response to you would be that you and I and others do this all the time and we should do this all the time. What I mean is that we should talk about things we have not had direct experience with because the Bible does give us a world view–a way to think about such things.

    Just this morning I met with a couple in adultery and, by the grace of God, I have no “experience” with that, but amazingly God is using our time together redemptively.

    This week a friend asked me to write about sexual abuse. Again, by the grace of God, I have no experience in such things, as an abuser or the abused. I was humbled that God has already used that article to encourage those who have been abused.

    A few years ago I wrote a critique about a movie and an “expert” said I should stick to my day job. I thought that was odd since God does give His children insight on things and I’m sure you’ve had (and have) opinions on things you’ve had no personal experience with. That is cool by me.

    The more important thing is how we share our “insight” and perspectives, i.e. grace and humility, which I believe Tracy has done here.

    As for children talking about menopause, it is a self-evident illustration. There needs to be more wisdom in years, experience, and God’s Word to speak, which a young age does not always give us time to develop.

    Tracy even made the point too–when she needs to understand menopause, she will seek out those who have more years, wisdom, and God’s Word under their belt.

    However, I do believe she possesses those things currently to proffer a perspective on home school.

    Thank you for reading and for caring enough to write. I hope this helps. – rick

  • Lorie

    I am thankful that in my life experience with homeschooling I have not seen this happen. I guess we were blessed to be in groups that were balanced in this area. We have 3 grown daughters who are married, ages 34, 32 and almost 30. Between their three families we now have 9 grandchildren with 2 on the way. I can honestly say that our girls learned at home how to run a home, but still had their girlhood left in tact. I agree with what some have said about there being problems on both sides of this issue, but I do believe that the way to learn to run a home is to practice at home learning the tasks needed. Our grandchildren are now being home schooled and we have 7 granddaughters out of 9 grandchildren. I believe that if you are aiming for the heart in your homeschooling and not for performance, if you are living out the gospel in your home and not legalism you do not have to worry about this happening. Thank you Tracy for helping homeschool parents to be aware of this tendency in some cases. Maybe it will be helpful in lessening the possibility of this happening to our daughters and granddaughters in the future. From a very blessed mother and grandmother.

  • http://www.RickThomas.Net/ Rick Thomas

    Well said, Kim. Thank you. Yes, it is a balance issue for sure. As a parent, I’m right with you in seeking to discern how and when to teach my kids to be adults, while guarding against Tracy’s appeal. – rick

  • http://www.RickThomas.Net/ Rick Thomas

    Well said, Gina. Thank you. This is a wise statement: “…let them grow in God’s timing and be the individuals God made them to be.” You used biblical wisdom fitted to the individual, the family, and the culture. Mercifully the Father has given you guys the wisdom to train your kids that way. I’m glad for you. Thank you for reading and writing. – rick

  • http://www.RickThomas.Net/ Rick Thomas

    You’re welcome, Tillery. I appreciate your kind and thoughtful response. I knew when I approved this article, it could be a “lightening rod,” so thank you for the manner in which you responded.

    I appreciated Tracy’s desire to steer away from blanket statements and absolutes, but only talking about “some” that she has seen. As a home school parent, we have some awareness of the good and the bad and are willing to enjoy the good, while bringing careful critique to the bad.

    As for your story, I appreciated your humility and how God has brought you through some challenging times. I will look at the website you mentioned.

    I liked this statement: “I was encouraged several years ago when I noticed that the tattoos outnumbered the denim skirts.” That brought a smile to me. Be blessed, rick

  • http://twitter.com/tillsims Tillery Sims

    I have been a part of homeschooling for almost 30 years. First as a student and now as a parent. I have to say that this is not a current trend as much as a recurring theme. I saw this as a teen and still feel the consequences of it as a mother.
    During the late 80′s and 90′s the push was through a movement that encouraged young men to not seek the approval of an ungodly institution (college) and for young women to learn to serve in their current and future homes. So as a girl I had 2 options marriage or midwifery. You can imagine the confusion and disappointment of the friends who have not married.
    This teaching ebbs and flows. Some teachers have been around for years some have latched on to the Reformation movement. For the last several years I have helped to organize a 6000+ conference for home schoolers in my home state. I look every year for speakers who are teaching grace and not the law but it is difficult to even find enough to balance out the options. There are always those families attending like you have described but many, many others. I was encouraged several years ago when I noticed that the tattoos outnumbered the denim skirts.
    What so many of us are looking for is a guarantee with our kids. That is what is being offered and it is so appealing. How sad it has been to see so many of these families broken and devastated by the choices their children make- sometime much later in life due to stifled rebellion. They not only lose their children but also lose their friends and at times their churches. They become who they have worked so desperately not to be – sinners on the outside.
    I know for myself that it was not the teacher as much as the fact that the teaching appealed to the pharisee in me and the fear in my parents. I am thankful for the years at Mt. Sinai because of the joy I now know through grace. The law is a harsh taskmaster but it makes Christ that much sweeter.
    If you would like to know more about what is being offered to the families that are coming out of the early movement you should visit http://www.recoveringgrace.org
    Thanks so much for being willing to discuss this issue.
    Blessings, Tillery

  • http://www.RickThomas.Net/ Rick Thomas

    BTW, Shawn, be sure to read my 12 Life Lessons for Teenagers. That will get more to your point: http://www.rickthomas.net/2012/06/18/life-lessons-teenagers/

  • http://twitter.com/Lamponastand Tyanne Perry

    I agree, Shawn. Thanks for sharing these thoughts. I think the awkwardness that may exist in the “pre-maturity” mentioned above is simply a temporary disconnect between the appropriately mature child and the rest of the culture. When you are more mature than your peers, you will have more difficulty relating with them, but I don’t consider this a negative disconnect.

  • http://www.RickThomas.Net/ Rick Thomas

    Hey Shawn, thanks for reading Tracy’s article. I appreciate you doing that. You’re so right in your comments. Actually you and Tracy present two real things in our culture, just from differing perspectives.

    As a counselor I see what you’re describing too often and it saddens my soul. Many adults in this culture do not know how to be biblical adults. It’s a huge problem.

    And what Tracy is describing is real too. Thanks again for reading and sharing your thoughts. I pray you and I will have many opportunities to speak into these things. Thanks so much, rick

  • Aimee Byrd

    There is a lot of wisdom here. My children are not homeschooled, but I particularly resonated with what you said about not expecting our daughters to dress and have interests the same as we do as mature adults. This makes a lot of sense, while challenging us as parents to guide our daughters, and also give them the experience to mature.

  • Shawn

    Interesting, with all due respect though, I think maybe you have bought into our cultures’ new concept and lifestyle definition of adolosecence. This is a life stage that I can’t find reference to in the bible. There are children and adults in scripture. A child is always training to be an adult and in biblical Hebrew culture boys were often considered men a 13. I think the bigger problem with our culture is delayed maturity. Boys and girls are encouraged to stay children and not put away childish things for way too long. Kids are still living at home at 26 and on their parents insurance. It isn’t only that the kids are growing up too fast, it is that they are growing in sinful habits and the sinful ways of the culture at all (often exposed way too early to sin before they are ready to refute it or understand its lies). Adopting the habits, skills and worldview of Godly parents is the whole point of Christian discipleship. Jesus said, “The student is not above his teacher, all students will become like their teacher.” (paraphrase)

  • http://www.facebook.com/bgbcsmith Gina Smith

    I appreciate you sharing this! I homeschooled both of my children, who are now in college. I noticed exactly what you are talking about! We reached a crossroads where we had to choose if we were going to make them be something prematurely, or let them grow in God’s timing and be the individuals God made them to be. We chose to let them be who they were made to be. The consequences were that we didn’t fit into the homeschool culture that we knew then, and were alone in much of what we did. It was lonely but worth it! We are now seeing the fruit of that decision and are so humbled and grateful that we made that choice. This is a much needed message for the homeschool community! Thank you for being brave enough to share it!

    http://www.keepinitrealgina.com

  • http://twitter.com/reformedgamer Ryan Wallace

    Tracy, as a young married guy who was homeschooled (and married a homeschooler), I can definitely relate to everything you said in this article. I have attended conferences and seen this first-hand. I have also seen a lot of these same girls (who are thrust into positions that their parents should be in) continue to stay at home, waiting for Mr. Right to come along and sweep them off into blissfulness.

    To me, the mindset stems from the same thing: parents are not accepting their own responsibility in these matters and allowing their children to actually grow up at a normal rate. There is a lot of Pharisaical thinking among the parents, and a lot of what I like to call “competition for godliness.” I also think that the “form of godliness” you referenced to can actually lead to full-blown rebellion against the faith and home-schooling in general. I know several friends who were homeschooled who practically denounced the faith they once claimed and lived in because honestly, it was more like slavery than the freedom Christ brings.

    I pray a lot of homeschooling parents read this article, and I plan on sharing it, as well.

    Thanks for your honesty and God bless.

  • Marcella Franseen

    Great article, Tracy! I’m not a homeschool mom but this was still a good reminder for me concerning my three kids. I love the strong point you made in the difference between a young woman and a woman and the reminder that the heart is more important than the outside appearance. I need to be aware of what I’m going after in my kids, the heart or their appearance.

  • Kim Shay

    I’ve seen the trends you mention here. However, that used to be the norm at one time when families had more than the typical 1.8 children, or whatever current statistics are. While this is definitely overdone, and young girls should have freedom to be little girls, I think it’s helpful for a young girl to have some ideas about mothering, and learn them from a mother or sister. My daughter is 23; her and her friends get their discipleship in such matters from Google. I think this pre-maturity is also seen in the world (despite the over-sexualization of the culture, which tells them to be grown women) with girls by not demanding that they take responsibility for anything.

    I think you may have some homeschool mothers who wince a little at being criticized for their daughters wanting to look like them.

    I homeschooled for eight years and my kids were in public school, so I’ve had both sides of the coin. Neither system is perfect, and both carry cautions.

%d bloggers like this: